Who this is for: Owners of acreage, hobby farms, cottages used as homes or unusual properties, who have equity but have been told the property is outside what their bank will lend on.
On this page
Living outside the city comes with a quiet disadvantage: a bank treats the property as unusual. Fewer comparable sales, a well instead of a water main, a septic field, a long gravel road, a barn that adds value to you and little to the appraiser. When equity is tied up in a place like that, a second mortgage is sometimes the only product on offer. Understand what the lender is looking at before you shop.
What a rural or non-standard second mortgage is
It is the same product as any second mortgage: a loan registered on your title behind the first mortgage. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada notes that second mortgages usually carry higher rates than first mortgages and that you must keep paying the first one. What changes is how the lender sees the property. A rural home, acreage, hobby farm or an unusual building may sit outside the standard rules that a bank’s automated process can handle.
Private lenders tend to look at the equity and the exit instead of fitting the property into a template. That flexibility is what makes the loan possible, and it is what you pay for.
When it makes sense
It makes sense when you have real equity, a bank has said the property does not fit its policy, and you have a use for the money that you can defend. Typical uses include a roof, a new septic system, a well, a barn repair, a debt that has grown at high interest, or taxes that need clearing.
It also makes sense when the property is stable and the income is steady but hard to document, as it can be for owners with farm, seasonal or self-employed income. A lender who focuses on equity can say yes where an income-based lender cannot.
If you plan to sell or refinance with a farm lender within a year or two, a short loan can bridge to that goal. The exit should be as specific as the loan.
When it makes things worse
It makes things worse when the value the lender sees is much lower than the value you hope for. A property that appraises at $400,000 will not support a loan sized for $500,000, as the first example above shows, and the appraisal fee is spent before you learn that.
It also goes wrong when the property is hard to sell. Rural homes can take longer to sell, and if the loan is short and the sale is the exit, a slow market is a real risk. A loan that comes due in twelve months is harder to survive when the home needs eighteen to sell.
And it is a bad idea when the payments rely on income from the land that may not appear. A bad harvest, a drought, a market that moves against you or a tenant who leaves can all hit the same year.
What it really costs
The second worked example shows a $70,000 loan costing $14,000 for a year on made-up assumptions, or 20% of the amount. Interest is the biggest line. Fees follow, and rural costs often include extras: an appraiser who has to travel, a survey, and well and septic inspections.
Per the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, expect appraisal, title search, title insurance and legal fees when you borrow against equity. Ask for each figure in dollars, in writing, and use the calculator to test the quote against your income.
Remember costs that are not in the loan. Borrowing against your home also uses up equity you might need later. Property taxes, insurance on outbuildings, fuel, and upkeep on a long driveway are costs you carry whatever the loan is.
The risk to the home
The property is the security. If you cannot repay, the lender can enforce the loan, and the agency warns that missing payments on a home equity loan can lead to serious consequences, including foreclosure. On a rural property, a forced sale can be slow and may realize less than a sale you control.
Water is a rural-specific risk to the property itself. A failed well or septic system can make the home hard to live in and hard to sell. Health Canada advises that you test your well water for E. coli and total coliform bacteria at least once every six months, and test other quality measures every two years. A lender may ask for results, and a bad result can change the value of the property.
Keep paying your first mortgage on time. A default can lead to action on the whole property.
Options to try first
Start with lenders that understand your type of property. A credit union with local roots, a farm lender or a bank’s agricultural group may lend where a mainstream branch will not. Ask them what they need: an appraisal on the house, the land, a survey, inspection results.
Consider a HELOC from a bank that will take the property, or a smaller loan that covers the urgent item rather than everything you want. If the loan is for repairs, read the page on renovation financing, which looks at staging work and sizing a loan with a cushion.
If you need a lump sum rather than a line of credit, the HELOC and second mortgage comparison shows how the two differ. Selling a parcel of land, if the property can be split, may raise money without any new debt, though it needs legal and municipal approval.
How the exit works
Write down how the loan ends before you sign. The usual routes are a refinance with a farm or rural lender after the property is better documented, the sale of a parcel or of the whole property, or a payoff from income you can show. A refinance depends on your income and an appraisal at that time. Test the plan with the appraisal lower and the sale slower than you hope.
Most private loans are short, with the full balance due at the end. Ask what the lender charges to extend, and whether the loan can be renewed if a sale takes longer.
What to ask before you sign
- How the lender values the house, the land and the outbuildings.
- What water, septic and access records the lender needs.
- The total cost of borrowing in dollars for the full term, with every fee shown, including inspections and travel.
- What you will still owe on the last day, and the cost to extend.
- What happens if the appraisal is lower than expected.
- The name of the licensed professional and how to check their licence with your provincial regulator.
Rules on land, family property and farms differ by province. If you want to talk to a licensed mortgage professional in your province, you can check your options. You are free to say no.
Two appraisals of the same acreage house
Made-up values. The owner believes the house and 10 acres are worth $500,000, while a lender's appraiser values the house and a limited area at $400,000. The first mortgage is $250,000. Uses the general 80% ceiling of appraised value described by the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada. Real lenders may set lower limits.
- First mortgage owing
- $250,000
- Room at the owner's $500,000 view
- $150,000
- Room at the appraiser's $400,000 value
- $70,000
- Difference in room to borrow
- $80,000
80% is $400,000, minus $250,000
80% is $320,000, minus $250,000
A $70,000 rural loan held for one year
Made-up figures only. An assumed 12% interest-only rate for one year, an assumed 2.5% lender fee, 1% broker fee, and $3,150 for legal costs, appraisal and title plus an assumed well and septic inspection.
- Interest for one year
- $8,400
- Lender fee
- $1,750
- Broker fee
- $700
- Legal, appraisal, title and inspections
- $3,150
- Cost to borrow for one year
- $14,000
$70,000 at 12%
2.5% of $70,000
1% of $70,000
Questions people ask
Why do banks turn down rural or acreage properties?
They worry about how easily the property could be sold, how to value land and outbuildings, and sometimes the water and septic systems. Policies vary by lender. A private lender may accept a property a bank will not, at a higher price and with more focus on the equity.
Will the lender count all my land?
Not always. Some lenders put the main value on the house and a limited area around it, and discount or ignore extra acres, outbuildings and farmland. Ask the licensed professional how the lender will treat your land before you pay for an appraisal.
Does the well and septic system matter to the loan?
It can. A lender may ask for water test results or a septic inspection. Health Canada advises testing well water for microbes at least once every six months, so keeping dated results helps both your health and your file.
Can I borrow against a hobby farm or a farm with income?
Some lenders treat a property with farm income differently from a rural home, and a commercial or agricultural lender may be a better fit. Tell the professional exactly how the land is used and who owns the equipment, buildings and livestock.
Is a cottage or recreational property treated the same way?
Often not. Lenders look at whether a road reaches it all year, whether you live there, and how easily it would sell. A cottage used as a main home is easier than a seasonal one. Ask what the lender needs and be honest about how you use it.